CW: Ableism & Eugenics
Disability has long been a source of public debate. A century ago, that concern was often framed through fears about heredity. Today, it is more likely to surface in debates about cost, employment, education, or public policy. The language changes, but the underlying question remains familiar: what happens when disabled people become more visible, more connected, and are part of society?
That question sits at the center of a renewed debate over Alexander Graham Bell. Over a century after his death, Parks Canada is reconsidering how to remember the inventor due to his opposition to sign language and concerns about Deaf people marrying. His descendants have challenged that portrayal, arguing that his views have been misunderstood and removed from their historical context. While the debate is rooted in Deaf history, it also reflects a much broader history of how society has viewed disability itself.
Bell opposed sign language and was a proponent of oralism, an educational approach that emphasized speech and lip-reading over sign language. He warned that residential schools for Deaf people would encourage Deaf-Deaf marriages and, through increased inheritance of deafness, create a “deaf variety of the human race.” His theory reflected the scientific assumptions of its era, when heredity was increasingly used to explain a wide range of medical conditions.
More than a century later, researchers finally had the tools to test Bell’s prediction. A 2020 study used population genetics and computer simulations to model what would happen if Deaf people preferentially married other Deaf people over many generations. The results did not support Bell’s fears. While such marriages could slightly increase the expression of certain forms of recessive deafness, the overall frequency of deafness-causing genes remained largely unchanged. The future that Bell envisioned never arrived.
What makes that finding compelling is not that Bell was wrong. It is how familiar the fear behind his argument feels. Throughout history, society has repeatedly feared that greater inclusion would bring consequences. Sometimes the concern centered on heredity. At other times it focused on education, public spending, productivity, or dependence. The reasoning changed, but the anxiety often remained.
For much of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, disabled people were treated as problems to manage, rather than people whose lives were valuable. Eugenics movements promoted the idea that some disabled people should not have children. Forced sterilization laws affected tens of thousands of Americans, while large institutions kept disabled people out of their communities.
In some places, keeping disabled people out of public view became part of the law itself. So-called “Ugly Laws,” enacted in several American cities during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, prohibited people with visible disabilities or disfigurements from appearing in public spaces. The message was unmistakably clear: disability was something to be hidden rather than accommodated.
As those systems gradually came under criticism, the fears did not disappear. Instead, they changed. Critics warned that disabled students would lower standards in neighborhood schools. Opponents of accessibility laws argued that accommodations would increase costs. Predictions of disruption frequently accompanied demands for inclusion. Yet history rarely unfolded as critics anticipated. Disabled people entered local schools, workplaces, and daily life. Accessibility expanded opportunities, and disability rights movements reshaped public expectations about who belongs in society and on what terms.
More than 140 years after Bell warned about the future of deafness, the most significant changes have not been genetic. They have been social. Deaf communities built culture, language, institutions, and advocacy organizations. Disabled people organized politically, challenged discriminatory policies, and demanded greater control over their own lives. What changed was not society’s genetic makeup, but the ability of disabled people to find one another, build community, and make their voices heard.
That may be the most important lesson in the debate over Bell. He feared that Deaf people finding one another would transform society through biology. Society was transformed, but not in the way he predicted. Communities formed. Advocacy movements emerged. Ideas about disability, civil rights, education, and belonging evolved. The transformation was social rather than genetic.
That is also why the debate feels surprisingly contemporary. The underlying question has never been limited to deafness. It is a question about what society expects when disabled people gather, organize, and participate more fully in public life. For much of history, the answer was framed in terms of risk. History suggests something different.
When disabled people began having more opportunities to participate in society, communities did not collapse. Schools did not fail. Society did not unravel. The outcomes were far better than critics anticipated.
The fear of disability has a long history. So does the history of disabled people finding one another. The distance between those two histories helps explain both how far society has come and how far it still has left to go.
Sources:
Braun, Derek C., et al. “Deaf Intermarriage Has Limited Effect on the Prevalence of Recessive Deafness and No Effect on Underlying Allelic Frequency.” PLOS ONE, vol. 15, no. 11, 2020, article e0241609, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0241609.
Coco, Adrienne Phelps. “Diseased, Maimed, Mutilated: Categorizations of Disability and an Ugly Law in Late Nineteenth-Century Chicago.” Journal of Social History, vol. 44, no. 1, 2010, pp. 23–37. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/40802107.
Jowers-Barber, Sandra. “The Complicated History of Deaf Education.” The New York Times, 1 Aug. 2011, https://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2011/07/31/do-states-need-schools-for-the-deaf/the-complicated-history-of-deaf-education.
Knight, Chris. “Alexander Graham Bell Descendants Upset After Parks Canada Calls Inventor a Eugenicist.” National Post, 5 Nov. 2026, https://nationalpost.com/news/alexander-graham-bell-descendants-upset-after-parks-canada-calls-inventor-a-eugenicist/.
Savich, Carl. Inclusion: The Pros and Cons—A Critical Review. Online Submission, 25 June 2008, https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED501775.pdf.
Schweik, Susan M. The Ugly Laws: Disability in Public. New York University Press, 2010.
Thompkins, Richard, and Pat Deloney. Inclusion: The Pros & Cons. Issues About Change, vol. 4, no. 3, Southwest Educational Development Laboratory, 1995, https://sedl.org/pubs/catalog/items/cha05.html.
